What remains confidential
Candor is what makes early resolution possible, and candor requires protection people can rely on.
We hold ourselves to a standard of discretion comparable to that of the privileged professions. The engagement is confidential by contract, and the parties intend that settlement communications be protected to the maximum extent provided by applicable law in the relevant jurisdiction. The scope of that protection varies by state.
Confidentiality for settlement talks has a long pedigree in American law. Federal Rule of Evidence 408 has barred the use of compromise negotiations to prove or disprove a disputed claim since 1975, the Alternative Dispute Resolution Act of 1998 requires every federal district court to protect the confidentiality of its mediation programs by local rule, and a line of federal decisions beginning with Folb v. Motion Picture Industry Pension Plans (C.D. Cal. 1998) recognizes a mediation privilege as a matter of federal common law.
The states built on that foundation. The Uniform Mediation Act, adopted in about a dozen jurisdictions, gives mediation communications a privilege that the parties and the mediator can each assert, and California went further: Evidence Code sections 1115 through 1128 make anything said or written for the purpose of a mediation inadmissible and undiscoverable in later civil proceedings, with exceptions the courts read narrowly.
A Project Neutral® engagement is structured to sit inside that framework. The Neutral is retained jointly by the parties for the purpose of resolving a dispute, every interview opens with a confirmation that it is a settlement communication, every deliverable carries the same designation, and the engagement agreement records the parties' shared intent that the protection apply. Whether a particular statement falls within a particular statute is a question for counsel in the relevant jurisdiction, and the Neutral never answers it for them.
We do not promise any particular evidentiary outcome in a future proceeding.
Interviews are conducted on a non-attribution basis, confirmed in writing before each one. Positions are recorded; individual statements are never attributed in any deliverable.
Information received from one party in caucus or in confidence is not disclosed to another party without the disclosing party's consent, and nothing from settlement discussions is carried into any later formal proceeding.
The engagement agreement includes covenants in which the parties agree not to call the Neutral to testify voluntarily and not to subpoena the Neutral's notes or testimony concerning settlement communications, except as applicable law requires.
Project Neutral® Inc. is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Counsel should advise each party on the scope of protection in the relevant jurisdiction. Counsel are welcome on the intake call. Most confidentiality questions are answered fastest there.